Scar management

Overview of Treatment

Scar management is a medical procedure aimed at repairing and improving scars formed after skin injury. The primary goal is to reduce redness, swelling, or contracture of the scar, while enhancing skin appearance and function. Treatment methods vary depending on the type and severity of the scar, and may include surgical procedures, medication therapy, physical therapy, or a combination of multiple techniques.

This treatment not only addresses aesthetic concerns but also focuses on the impact of scars on patients’ quality of life, such as limited mobility around joints or psychological distress caused by appearance changes. Physicians will develop personalized treatment strategies based on the scar’s formation time, location, and patient needs.

Types and Mechanisms of Treatment

1. Surgical Excision: Removal of hypertrophic scar tissue through surgery, followed by re-suturing of the wound. This process can directly reduce scar volume and is often combined with Z-plasty techniques to minimize the risk of new scar formation. 2. Laser Therapy: Using specific wavelength lasers to stimulate collagen remodeling, such as pulsed dye lasers for vascular hypertrophic scars, and CO2 lasers for surface smoothing of scars. 3. Silicone Products: Silicone gels or sheets maintain a moist wound environment, regulate moisture balance to reduce itching and redness, possibly by modulating cytokine secretion.

4. Corticosteroid Injections: Direct injection of corticosteroids into scar tissue to inhibit fibroblast activity, reduce scar size, and alleviate pain. 5. Radiation Therapy: Postoperative low-dose radiation to prevent scar recurrence, mainly used for large or recurrent scars.

Indications

Suitable for the following types of scars:

  • Hypertrophic Scar: Raised and red but confined within the wound boundary
  • Keloid: Abnormally expanding scar tissue
  • Burn Contracture Scar: Limiting joint movement or affecting organ function
  • Acne or Traumatic Hypertrophic or Atrophic Scars

Also applicable for postoperative scar improvement and aesthetic defect repair. Note that some therapies are more effective on new scars (within 6 months), while older scars may require multi-stage treatment.

Usage and Dosage

Surgical treatment requires local or general anesthesia, with excision scope considering surrounding tissue tension. Laser treatments are usually performed every 4-6 weeks, with total sessions adjusted based on scar depth (commonly 3-6 sessions). Silicone products should be used at least 12 hours daily, recommended for continuous use over 3-6 months for optimal results.

Injection treatments depend on scar size; for example, Triamcinolone is commonly used at 10-40 mg/mL concentration, administered every 4-8 weeks. Radiation doses should be calculated by a radiation oncologist based on scar volume, typically kept below 20 Gy to avoid tissue damage.

Benefits and Advantages

Main effects include:

  • Improvement of scar color and texture to match surrounding skin
  • Restoration of joint mobility and relief from contracture-related functional impairment
  • Reduction of symptoms such as itching and pain

Advantages include:

  • Most non-invasive therapies have short recovery periods, suitable for daily use
  • Combination of different therapies based on scar type, such as surgical excision followed by laser repair
  • Modern therapies have controllable side effects and significantly improved safety compared to past methods

Risks and Side Effects

Possible short-term reactions include:

  • Redness and blisters after laser treatment (usually subsiding in 7-10 days)
  • Temporary pallor or bruising at injection sites
  • Contact dermatitis from silicone products (incidence about 3-5%)

Serious risks include:

  • Infection or wound dehiscence after surgery
  • Skin atrophy or pigmentation loss from radiation therapy
  • Repeated treatments may cause scar hardening or formation of new abnormal scars

Precautions and Contraindications

Before treatment, attention should be paid to:

  • Infected wounds should not undergo immediate treatment
  • Patients with coagulation disorders need to adjust anticoagulant medication
  • Pregnant women should avoid radiation or certain chemical therapies

Contraindications include:

  • Allergy to silicone components
  • Active skin diseases (e.g., eczema, ulcers)
  • Contraindications for radiation therapy (e.g., deep tissue damage in head and neck)

Interactions with Other Treatments

Avoid using retinoic acid derivatives within 24 hours after laser therapy to prevent increased skin irritation. Oral anticoagulants should be discussed with a physician; they may need to be temporarily stopped to reduce intraoperative bleeding risk. Cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy should inform their doctor, as radiation therapy may increase tissue damage.

Topical corticosteroid ointments can be combined with silicone products but should be spaced 2-3 hours apart to prevent excessive absorption. For autologous skin graft recipients, laser therapy should be started 2 weeks post-surgery to ensure wound healing.

Treatment Outcomes and Evidence

Clinical studies show that silicone sheets can improve 70-90% of hypertrophic scars within 6 months. Sequential pulsed dye laser treatments have an 85% efficacy rate for acne scars, with long-term follow-up showing recurrence rates below 15%. Surgical excision combined with postoperative radiation therapy can reduce keloid recurrence from 40-50% to below 10%.

The 2018 systematic review indicates that combining 585nm pulsed dye laser with pressure garments can reduce burn scar thickness by 40%. Randomized controlled trials confirm that triple pulsed laser treatments every 8 weeks significantly improve scar redness and swelling (p<0.05).

Alternatives

If primary therapies are unsuitable, options include:

  • Pressure therapy: long-term compression with elastic fabrics, suitable for extensive burn scars
  • Autologous fat transfer: filling depressed scars, especially for facial contour restoration
  • 5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) injections: suppress fibroblast activity as an alternative to corticosteroid injections

Other options include:

  • Microneedling to stimulate collagen regeneration
  • Pulsed magnetic field therapy to promote tissue repair
  • Oral vitamin E and pro-collagen supplements (to be used under medical supervision)

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What preparations are needed before scar management?

Prior to treatment, the affected area should be cleaned, avoiding alcohol-based or irritating cosmetics. If undergoing laser or surgical procedures, inform the doctor of any allergies or medications (such as anticoagulants). Skin sensitivity tests may also be performed before treatment to prevent adverse reactions.

Do different types of scars (such as hypertrophic scars or keloids) require different treatment approaches?

Yes. Hypertrophic scars are often treated with corticosteroid injections or pressure therapy, while keloids may require combined laser and surgical excision. The doctor will tailor the plan based on scar shape, location, and severity. For example, small facial scars might be prioritized for microdermabrasion, while deep scars may need skin grafts.

Is it normal to experience itching or swelling after scar treatment? How should it be handled?

Mild itching and swelling are common reactions and usually subside within 1-2 weeks. Cold compresses or prescribed anti-inflammatory ointments can be used, but scratching should be avoided. If fever, pus, or persistent severe pain occurs, seek medical attention promptly, as it may indicate infection or allergic reaction.

Is it normal for scar color to deepen after multiple treatments?

Yes, scar color may initially darken before gradually fading, which is part of the normal healing process. Improvement is usually seen within 3-6 months. If the color continues to deepen and is accompanied by hardness or pain, a follow-up is necessary to assess whether treatment parameters are excessive or if chronic inflammation exists.

How can diet or skincare in daily life prolong the effects of scar management?

Increasing intake of vitamin C and protein-rich foods (such as leafy greens and fish) can promote collagen synthesis. Avoid spicy or allergenic foods to reduce inflammation. Daily use of SPF30 or higher sunscreen and avoiding direct sunlight on treated areas for at least 6 months can prevent pigmentation issues.